Free library · guide · 12 minutes
Giving feedback people can actually use.
Engineers give feedback every week: in design reviews, on inspections, on a graduate's report, after a colleague's presentation. Done well, it makes the work and the person better. Done badly, it can make things worse. Here's how to do it well, at a speaking club and at work.
Feedback can backfire
A large review of feedback research by Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi found that in about a third of cases, feedback actually made performance worse. The common thread: feedback that pulled attention onto the person ("you're disorganised") rather than the task ("the cost table came before the options, so I couldn't follow the comparison").
So three rules sit underneath everything on this page:
- About the work, not the person. Describe what they did, not who they are.
- Specific. Say what you saw, heard and felt, with an example. "Good job" and "needs work" give the person nothing to use.
- Useful. One or two changes they can make next time. Not ten.
Evaluating a speech: the Toastmasters approach
Toastmasters clubs have refined the spoken evaluation over decades. Every speech gets a short evaluation of two to three minutes from another member. The approach, in short:
- Prepare. Find out beforehand what the speaker is working on, and evaluate against that, not against your own ideal speech.
- Speak from your own point of view. "I felt", "I noticed", "I'd suggest", rather than "you should" or "you failed to".
- Commend. Start with one or two things that genuinely worked, with a specific example of each, so they keep doing them.
- Recommend. One or two improvements, each with how to do it. "Next time, try pausing for two seconds before your key number" is useful. "Work on your pauses" isn't.
- Commend again. Finish with encouragement, so the speaker wants to come back and speak again.
- Critique the speech, not the speaker. Notice signs of nerves and be kind about them.
If you're a Toastmaster, your club's evaluation resources and the Pathways evaluation forms go into far more detail. Use them alongside this page.
What to look for in a presentation
You don't have to comment on everything. Watch for these, then pick the one or two that will make the biggest difference.
Purpose
Was it clear what the speaker wanted the audience to know, decide or do?
Structure
Did it open with the point? Could you follow where it was going?
Clarity
Were the words plain? Were technical terms explained for this audience?
Voice
Did pitch, pace, volume and pauses help you hear what mattered?
Body
Did stance, gestures and eye contact support the words or distract from them?
Audience
Did the speaker adapt to who was in the room, and handle questions well?
Close
Did it finish clearly, with a next step or a final point that stuck?
At work: Situation, Behaviour, Impact
At a speaking club, everyone has signed up for feedback. At work, they often haven't, and the stakes are higher. The SBI model from the Center for Creative Leadership keeps workplace feedback factual and hard to argue with.
- Situation: when and where. "In this morning's design review…"
- Behaviour: what they did, as a camera would have recorded it. "…you cut in twice while Priya was raising the drainage issue…"
- Impact: the effect it had. "…she stopped contributing, and we nearly signed off without dealing with it."
Then ask, and listen: "What was going on for you there?" Often there is a reason you didn't know about. CCL calls this extra step intent.
Feedforward
Marshall Goldsmith suggests sometimes skipping the past entirely and offering ideas for the future instead: "For the next client meeting, you could try leading with the recommendation." People can't argue with the future, so it tends to land with less defensiveness.
A word on the "feedback sandwich"
Commend, recommend, commend works well in a learning setting like a speaking club, where the aim is to build confidence. At work, when there is a real problem, wrapping it in praise can bury it. The person remembers the compliments and misses the message. When it matters, be clear and direct, and be kind in how you say it, not vague in what you say.
Build your feedback
Fill in the boxes and your feedback is assembled underneath, ready to copy into an email or read out. Nothing you type leaves your browser.
Read it out loud before you send it. If it sounds like a verdict on the person, rewrite it about the work.
Receiving feedback well
In Thanks for the Feedback, Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen point out that we push back on feedback for three reasons: we think it's wrong, we have a problem with who is giving it, or it hits our sense of who we are. Knowing which one is going on helps you get past it.
- Say thank you, and nothing else, at first. Defending yourself in the moment teaches people not to bother next time.
- Ask for an example. "Can you tell me where you noticed that?" turns a general comment into something you can use.
- Decide later what to use. You don't have to accept every piece of feedback. You do have to hear it.
Practise
Watch a short talk online, such as one of the videos in this library, and give it a two-minute evaluation using commend, recommend, commend. Record yourself in the practice room and play it back. Did your feedback sound specific and kind?
Definitions
- Evaluation
- Structured feedback on a speech or presentation, given so the speaker can improve. The Toastmasters term for a short spoken review given after each speech.
- Commend, recommend, commend
- A structure for spoken evaluations: start with what worked, give one or two specific improvements, and finish with encouragement.
- SBI
- Situation, Behaviour, Impact. A feedback model from the Center for Creative Leadership: describe when and where, what the person did, and what effect it had.
- Feedforward
- Marshall Goldsmith’s term for suggestions about the future instead of critique of the past.
- "I" statement
- Feedback phrased from your own point of view ("I lost the thread when…") rather than as a verdict ("You were confusing").
- Toastmasters International: How to evaluate effectively (Toastmaster magazine)
- Toastmasters International: 5 tips for effective feedback (Toastmaster magazine, 2019)
- Center for Creative Leadership: the Situation-Behavior-Impact feedback model
- Marshall Goldsmith: Try feedforward instead of feedback
- Kluger and DeNisi (1996), The effects of feedback interventions on performance, Psychological Bulletin Meta-analysis: in about a third of cases, feedback made performance worse.
- Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen, Thanks for the Feedback (2014), on receiving feedback well.
Everything here is free. If you ever want one-on-one help with your own material, coaching is available →